---
title: "Delhi High Court Denies Interim Injunction in Copyright Dispute Over Law Books, Holds Chain of Title Must Be Prima Facie Established"
date: 2026-11-19
author: "King Stubb &amp; Kasiva"
url: https://ksandk.com/newsletter/copyright-chain-of-title-law-books-injunction/
---

# Delhi High Court Denies Interim Injunction in Copyright Dispute Over Law Books, Holds Chain of Title Must Be Prima Facie Established

Posted On - 19 November, 2026 • By - King Stubb & Kasiva

## **Summary**

The Delhi High Court, in Mrs. Shakti Sagar v. The Delhi Law House & Ors., declined to grant an interim injunction in a copyright dispute concerning 47 literary works. The Court held that the plaintiff had failed to establish a prima facie copyright ownership, as the chain of title originating from the respective authors was not demonstrated through valid assignments. The Court emphasised that inheritance through a Will cannot confer rights that the testator did not establish.

## **Facts of the Case**

The plaintiff, widow of late Mr. Subhash Sagar and daughter-in-law of late Mr. R.G. Sagar, claimed copyright ownership over 47 literary works, alleging that the defendants were publishing and selling these works without her authorisation.

Her claim was based on a certificate dated 1 April 1962, allegedly recording the transfer of copyrights from M/s Law Book Company to late Mr. R.G. Sagar, followed by his Will dated 17 October 1995 in favour of his son, late Mr. Subhash Sagar, and a subsequent Will dated 21 January 2021 in favour of the plaintiff.

The plaintiff alleged that the defendants were exploiting the works through a newly constituted partnership firm, The Delhi Law House (TDLH), without her authorisation. The judgment distinguishes TDLH, constituted in 2021 by Defendant Nos. 2 and 3, from the longstanding Delhi Law House (DLH), a family partnership stated to have been in existence since 1981. The plaintiff claimed that she had permitted DLH to publish the works but had not authorised TDLH to do so. She accordingly sought an interim injunction restraining the defendants from using and publishing the works.

## **Issue before the Court**

Whether the plaintiff had established a prima facie right over the literary works, based on the alleged chain of copyright ownership and testamentary succession, warranting an interim injunction against the defendants.

## **Findings of the Court**

The Court observed that under Section 17 of the Copyright Act, 1957, the author is the first owner of copyright. A person other than the author can derive ownership through a valid assignment under Sections 18 and 19, which requires a written instrument signed by the assignor or their authorised agent.

The Court also considered the position concerning works published before the Copyright Act, 1957 came into force. It observed that the earlier copyright legislation applicable in India also required assignments to be in writing and signed by the copyright owner or their authorised agent.

The Court noted that the books bore the names of their respective authors, but the plaintiff had not placed on record any assignment establishing how M/s Law Book Company had acquired copyright from those authors. The certificate dated 1 April 1962, even if accepted as recording a transfer to late Mr. R.G. Sagar, could not establish the root of the title in the absence of the underlying assignments.

The Court further observed that the two Wills relied upon by the plaintiff could not cure this deficiency, as a legatee can inherit only the rights held by the testator. The genuineness and effect of the testamentary documents were also disputed and required examination at trial.

The Court further noted that the plaintiff had not established a prima facie case of passing off. The goodwill relied upon was associated with the longstanding DLH partnership, rather than the plaintiff personally. The Court also clarified that the Wills had not been proved and that their genuineness and legal effect would require examination at trial.

Applying the principles governing interim injunctions, the Court held that the plaintiff had failed to establish a prima facie right. It also found that the balance of convenience did not favour the plaintiff and that the alleged loss of revenue was quantifiable and compensable through damages.

## **Held**

The Court dismissed the application for interim injunction, holding that the plaintiff had failed to satisfy the three essential requirements of a prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury.

The Court clarified that all observations were prima facie and that questions concerning authorship, assignment, the genuineness and effect of the Wills, and the parties’ respective rights would be decided at trial.

## **Conclusion**

The decision reiterates that a claim to copyright through testamentary succession must be supported by an established chain of title originating from the author or another lawful copyright owner. A Will or subsequent transfer cannot, by itself, establish copyright ownership where the testator’s underlying title remains unproven. The ruling also underscores the importance of establishing all three requirements before seeking interim protection in copyright infringement proceedings.

*Last Updated on 19 November, 2026*

Get King Stubb & Kasiva’s legal updates in your Google feed[![Add King Stubb & Kasiva as a preferred source on Google](https://ksandk.com/wp-content/uploads/google_preferred_source_badge_light_en@2x.png)](https://www.google.com/preferences/source?q=https://ksandk.com/)

---

## Office Locations                                                                                                                                                     
                                               
  - [New Delhi](https://ksandk.com/locations/top-corporate-law-firm-in-delhi/) (HQ): +91-11-41318190 | info@ksandk.com                                                    
  - [Mumbai](https://ksandk.com/locations/top-corporate-law-firm-in-mumbai/): 3 offices (Nariman Point, Lower Parel, Andheri) | mumbai@ksandk.com
  - [Bangalore](https://ksandk.com/locations/top-corporate-law-firm-in-bangalore/): bangalore@ksandk.com                                                                  
  - [Chennai](https://ksandk.com/locations/chennai/): chennai@ksandk.com                                                                                                  
  - [Hyderabad](https://ksandk.com/locations/hyderabad/): hyderabad@ksandk.com                                                                                            
  - [Pune](https://ksandk.com/locations/pune/): pune@ksandk.com                                                                                                           
  - [Kochi](https://ksandk.com/locations/kochi/): kochi@ksandk.com
                                                                                                                                                                          
  ## Contact                                   
                                                                                                                                                                          
  - [Contact Page](https://ksandk.com/contact-us/)
  - General: info@ksandk.com | +91-11-41318190
  - WhatsApp: +91-7428567444
  - [Privacy Statement](https://ksandk.com/privacy-statement/)                                                                                                            
  - [Terms of Use](https://ksandk.com/terms-of-use/)