Delhi High Court Decrees ANI’s Copyright Infringement Suit Against RSY News Through Summary Judgment

Posted On - 19 November, 2026 • By - King Stubb & Kasiva

Summary

The Delhi High Court, in ANI Media Pvt. Ltd. v. RSY News & Anr., decreed ANI Media’s copyright infringement suit through summary judgment under Order XIII-A CPC, read with Rule 27 of the Delhi High Court Intellectual Property Rights Division Rules, 2022. The Court held that the unauthorised reproduction of ANI’s news videos on YouTube amounted to copyright infringement and rejected the defendant’s defence of fair dealing for reporting current events.

Facts of the Case

ANI Media instituted the suit against RSY News and Google LLC alleging that RSY News had uploaded twelve videos across four YouTube channels, reproducing, wholly or substantially, ten of ANI’s original videos without authorisation.

ANI placed on record comparative screenshots showing that its logo remained visible in the infringing videos, with RSY News’ mark superimposed on the frames. While an ex-parte injunction was granted on 18 November 2024, RSY News failed to appear or file its written statement despite service and was proceeded against ex-parte. Google contested the proceedings in its capacity as an intermediary.

Issue before the Court

Whether the suit could be decreed through summary judgment under Order XIII-A CPC and whether the reproduction of ANI’s videos could be justified as fair dealing under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act, 1957.

Findings of the Court

The Court, relying upon Su-Kam Power Systems Ltd. v. Kunwer Sachdev and Reliance Eminent Trading and Commercial Private Limited v. Delhi Development Authority (2026 INSC 436), reiterated that summary judgment may be granted where the defendant has no real prospect of successfully defending the claim and no compelling reason exists for a trial.

The Court held that ANI had established copyright ownership in the original videos, which qualified as cinematograph films under Section 2(f) of the Copyright Act. It further observed that ten of the twelve infringing videos reproduced the original videos either entirely or virtually in their entirety.

Rejecting the fair-dealing defence, the Court observed that wholesale reproduction of ANI’s videos operated as a substitute for the original works. It also rejected the purported licence from Swami Entertainment Pvt. Ltd., which RSY News had failed to produce despite the plaintiff’s specific denial.

Held

The Court allowed the summary judgment application and permanently restrained RSY News from reproducing, uploading, publishing, distributing or otherwise exploiting ANI’s copyrighted works without authorisation. RSY News was also directed to remove the twelve identified infringing videos and other infringing content, to the extent not already removed.

The Court confirmed the directions against Google LLC for taking down and disabling access to the twelve identified URLs. However, the claims for damages and public acknowledgment were declined.

Conclusion

The decision reinforces the use of summary judgment in copyright infringement proceedings where documentary evidence establishes ownership and unauthorised reproduction, leaving no genuine issue requiring a full-fledged trial. It also clarifies that the fair-dealing exception for reporting current events cannot justify wholesale reproduction of copyrighted news footage.

Last Updated on 19 November, 2026

Get King Stubb & Kasiva’s legal updates in your Google feedAdd King Stubb & Kasiva as a preferred source on Google