Role of AIFs in Financing Startups and SMEs

Introduction:

The advent of Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) has significantly enriched India’s startup and SME financing in the intricate tapestry. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) operates these pivotal financial entities under its vigilant eye, adhering to the stipulations of the SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012.^[1] AIFs provide a structured, regulated conduit for funneling investments into non-traditional assets’ less-trodden terrain. This research article explores the nuanced role of AIFs in financially nurturing startups and SMEs by traversing through their evolutionary path, regulatory frameworks, impacts, and emergent trends.

Evolution and Growth of AIFs in India:

Punctuation Enhancement: AIFs in India have traversed a remarkable journey: segmented into three distinct phases, each hallmarked by pivotal regulatory and market evolutions.

1. Venture Capital Era (1988-2003):

India started the beginning of AIFs by adopting venture capital as a key method for investing in growing businesses. The authorities, with the Venture Capital Guidelines from 1988 that were still in an early stage, laid down some initial rules even if it was done quite crudely. These guidelines were seen as triggers for investment into growing sectors like technology and biotechnology.

The following arrival of the SEBI (Venture Capital Funds) Regulations in 1996 gave a strong structure to venture capital funds, increasing their range and creating environment for private investments in unlisted area. The time was mainly about supporting new startups ready to grow rapidly but lacking typical funding paths.

Warburg Pincus, a private equity firm, invested in Bharti Televentures Ltd. This showed how private equity funds could bring change to important economic areas. Many venture capital funds started growing with help from public sector financial institutions and they provided much-needed venture capital to new ventures in their early stages during this time.^[2]

2. Growth Phase (2003-2012):

The next period was a time when private equity became powerful in India’s investment world. It had many different types of investments that were big and spread across various sectors. The rise of the local capital market played an important role in making this happen; technology, real estate, and infrastructure were some areas where there were notable investments during this era.

In this phase, the government made improvements to regulations with the goal of creating a friendlier environment for private equity investments. The combination of investment rules and the start of stronger regulatory structures drew in significant foreign money. During this time, many private equity firms from all over the world also joined the Indian market which increased trust among local investors.

Crafting exit conduits for investors was a key part of this phase. The maturation of capital markets and the introduction of new financial tools made it possible to create various ways out, like public offerings or strategic divestitures, which increased the attraction for private equity investments in Indian market.

3. Consolidation and Transformation (2012-Present):

The stage we are presently in, which started with the SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations of 2012, is one of consolidation and transformation for AIFs. These regulations established a complete structure to manage the operations of AIFs; they divided these funds into three categories according to their investment tactics and focus on specific sectors.

To make it more human: These rules were made by SEBI with the goal of increasing transparency and protecting the interests of investors. They said that all AIFs must register, set investment limits, and give different operational directions. The purpose behind these actions was to increase the trustworthiness of AIFs so as to attract more institutional as well as retail investors into this area.

AIF investment strategies experienced a change in focus during this time. Before, venture capital and private equity were the main areas of interest but with these new regulations, they made room for wider range of investments like real estate, hedge funds and social ventures. This spreading out directed investments into different non-traditional sectors which grew the reach and influence of AIFs.

Types of AIFs:

The AIF scene in India is divided into three categories, each having its own focus and governance.

1. Category I AIFs:

Primarily invested in sectors considered socially or economically beneficial, these AIFs typically receive governmental benefits that encourage investments into certain areas.

Venture Capital Funds (VCFs) focus on early-stage startups that are full of potential. They provide necessary risk capital and strategic input, helping these startups to increase their operations.

In the early stage, angel funds invest in embryonic startups and are usually supported by high-net-worth individuals, providing not just money but also guidance and business expertise.

Infrastructure funds have a crucial part in funding big projects, such as roads and energy, they fill important gaps in our infrastructure system while also pushing economic growth.

Social Venture Funds: When it comes to these funds, the focus lies in investing money into businesses that feel a deep commitment towards social responsibility. They are not only interested in making profits but also want to bring about good changes within society. These types of investments frequently get placed into areas such as healthcare services, education systems or clean power production because they can have genuine effects on individuals’ wellbeing and environment protection.

2. Category II AIFs:

These AIFs, which are neither Category I nor III and have no leverage apart from operational necessities, fall under Category II.

Private Equity Funds improve value and get high returns when leaving by concentrating on non-publicly traded firms, giving important growth money to older businesses.

Debt Funds: The focus here is on investing in debt securities from firms not publicly listed. These funds offer structured debt solutions, which are crucial for smaller and medium-sized businesses as they let them expand their operations without losing any ownership stakes.

Fund of Funds: These funds invest in different Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs), which can help to distribute risk and increase returns for investment portfolios.

3. Category III AIFs:

These AIFs involve using different trading tactics and might use the option to leverage by means of either listed or unlisted derivatives.

Pipe funds give special fluid money to publicly listed entities. These funds invest in public companies, usually getting a discount.

To maximize returns, hedge funds use a mix of methods such as leveraging and short selling. They target high-net-worth individuals and institutional investors.

Regulatory Framework:

The SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012 are a full guideline that sets out how AIFs should register and operate in India. These rules aim to make the sector transparent, safeguard investors’ interests and promote growth of alternative investments in the country.

1. Registration Requirements:

Mandatory registration: Before starting their operations, AIFs have to register with SEBI. They must reveal full details about the fund’s structure, strategies and main staff members. This is done to guarantee credibility and structure in the market.

2. Investment Limits:

SEBI, in many cases, sets the lowest amount of investment to serve a complex group of investors. Normally, they require you invest at least Rs. 1 crore as your minimum commitment.

3. Operational Restrictions:

AIFs need to follow certain operational restrictions according to their category. Category I and II AIFs are generally not allowed to use leverage, while Category III AIFs can employ complex trading strategies. Stringent disclosure norms are also followed for keeping investors informed.

4. Reporting and Compliance:

SEBI, for keeping transparency and responsibility, AIFs must follow periodic reporting. They need to submit their financial statements and details about investors. Frequently done audits and checks for following norms are needed.

Impact on Startups and SMEs:

Financing and Growth: AIFs have become a game-changer for startups and small businesses in the US, providing them with specialized funding options like equity and debt financing that perfectly fit their specific requirements.

Equity Financing: AIFs are all about investing in startups and giving them the much-needed capital to scale up their business operations. This kind of funding is absolutely crucial for these companies to grow and succeed.

AIFs offer structured debt instruments that are crucial for SMEs to expand operations without equity dilution in debt financing.

Market Access and Visibility:

AIFs enhance market access and visibility for startups and SMEs. Startups are increasingly migrating to the SME exchange, which provides growth capital and market prominence. The exchange has witnessed over 800 IPOs with substantial post-migration returns, highlighting the critical role of AIFs in providing visibility and liquidity.

Recent Trends in the AIF Sector:

Increasing Fundraising and Investment Activity: Investors, from within the country and outside it too, have displayed a noticeable fascination for the lively AIF sector in India. There has been an evident rise in fundraising activities as well as investments made into this area. This growing interest is mirrored by a greater number of AIFs being registered with SEBI. The supportive regulatory environment and changing market situations have made India’s investment field more suitable for alternative investments, adding to this increase.

Fundraising Accomplishments: Fresh data demonstrates that recently, AIFs have collected a significant amount of money. They gathered more than ₹1.8 lakh crore in total during the fiscal year 2021-22, which shows how investors are gaining trust in alternative investments. This large sum of cash is being directed into different sectors such as technology, real estate and consumer goods to exhibit the varied investment methods employed by AIFs (AIF).

We have witnessed a significant rise in the money injected into startups and small businesses. It is crucial to underline that venture capital and private equity funds have been instrumental in supplying the needed capital for these expanding companies. The increase in cash has permitted startups to launch rapidly, as well as assisting small businesses to fortify their activities and boost general economic advancement.

Sectoral Diversification: AIFs are spreading their investments among a range of sectors, showing a broad method for distributing capital. This strategy of diversification helps to reduce risks and increase the chance for profitable returns.

Technology and Innovation: AIF investments, like many other types of financial support, give a significant amount to start-ups in technology. These funds help to create new ideas and developments in areas such as fintech (technology used for financial services), healthtech (technology for health care) and edtech (educational technology). These fields have shown strong potential for growth. AIFs are important supporters of advancements in technology and play a key part in pushing India’s digital economy ahead.

Real estate-focused AIFs have been key in directing funds towards big infrastructure plans, matching the rising requirements of city development. These investments assist not only in building commercial and housing structures but also aid to reinforce important infrastructure like highways and harbors.

AIFs, which have a strong consumer approach, are providing capital into companies that serve the increasing desire for high-quality products and services in sectors like retailing, food and drinks as well as lifestyle. The rise of spending power among consumers is leading to major growth within these industries.

Innovation in Investment Strategies:

AIFs are adopting new investment methods to maximize returns and skillfully handle risks. These methods consist of using a blend of equity and debt finance, making use of derivatives, as well as using structured products in their investments.

Numerous AIFs are adopting hybrid investment models that meld equity and debt financing. These AIFs offer an attractive risk-reward dynamic, appealing to investors who seek stable returns paired with growth opportunities. Investors particularly find hybrid funds prevalent in the real estate sector, offering both capital appreciation and rental yields.

Structured Products: Industry professionals are increasingly using structured products within Category III AIFs. They customize these products to meet the nuanced demands of sophisticated investors, aiming to yield specific risk-return profiles. These instruments often incorporate intricate financial tools such as derivatives, which enable risk hedging and return enhancement.

Impact Investing: The Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) landscape is witnessing a surge in impact investing. Impact funds focus on creating tangible social and environmental benefits in addition to financial returns. These funds are actively engaged in sectors such as clean energy, sustainable agriculture, and social infrastructure, contributing significantly to the broader goals of sustainable development.

Challenges and Future Prospects:

While the AIF sector is experiencing robust growth, it needs to address several challenges in order to maintain this momentum.

Regulatory Hurdles:

The regulatory framework, although comprehensive, can at times present as convoluted and onerous for fund managers: simplifying regulatory procedures and providing unambiguous guidelines may engender a more propitious climate for AIFs.

Compliance costs can deter smaller funds due to the heft of stringent regulatory requisites. Streamlining compliance measures and reducing associated costs may incentivize more funds to enter the market and flourish.

AIFs can be perplexed by the taxation landscape, which features disparate tax treatments for different fund categories. Governments should elucidate tax policies and offer incentives for long-term investments to bolster the allure of AIFs to both domestic and foreign investors.

Market Volatility:

Returns can be influenced by market volatility, thus AIF performance might experience variations. The creation of strong risk management structures and spreading investments across different types of assets could aid in reducing the impacts caused by changes within markets.

Inflation, interest rates, and global economic trends can significantly impact the performance of Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs). It is essential to ensure these funds have strategies in place to manage economic uncertainties and maintain investor confidence.

AIFs often face liquidity challenges due to the illiquid nature of many alternative investments. To attract a broader range of investors, it is crucial to provide avenues for secondary market transactions and enhance liquidity options within AIFs.

Future Prospects:

The horizon for the AIF sector in India is looking bright, pushed by good changes in regulations, more investor understanding and increasing need for other types of investments. Various major trends are likely to shape the path of the AIF sector.

Digital Transformation: The use of digital technologies in managing funds and making investments is likely to result in better functioning and improved interaction with investors. Exciting technologies such as blockchain, artificial intelligence can increase transparency, assist in decision making, and reduce costs for daily operations.

Green Investments: Investments that are friendly to the environment and sustainable are ready to take off, as AIFs include environmental, social and governance (ESG) measurements in their strategies. This change is driven by the understanding of how important it is to have sustainable development and a rising wish from investors for responsible investment opportunities. We can say for sure this trend will continue increasing.

Globalizing Investments: AIFs from India will need to expand their investment perspective, including more global markets. This will allow them to access a wider range of assets and diversify portfolios, enhancing the variety and potential earnings for AIF collections.

National Reports and Statistics:

Recent national reports indicate a substantial increase in the assets managed by Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) in India, underscoring the evolving investment landscape and the growing preference for alternative investment avenues. Investments in the Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) sector, which plays a critical role in job creation and significantly contributes to GDP, remain a key focus for AIFs.

Impact of RBI’s Revised Notification on AIFs:

Enhancement with Punctuation: On 27 March 2024, a notification^[3] was spread by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) that introduced important changes to rules which affect AIFs in regulatory context. This Revised Notification has relaxed certain orders from a previous notification dated on 19 December 2023, aiming at the bad practice of evergreening loans – where lenders offer new loans to pay off existing debts – and stopping these loans being called non-performing assets (NPAs).

Previous Notification: Key Provisions:

The antecedent notification established stringent directives to tackle evergreening:

Limit on more investments: Lenders were restricted from further investment into AIF schemes that had already invested in borrowers they had dealt with within the past year.

If an AIF, where the lender had invested, gave out funds to a borrower, the lender needs to make it liquidate within 30 days.

Rules about Provisioning: Back then, if lenders were unable to sell their investment within the fixed time period, they had to put aside 100% of it.

Limitations on the Model of Priority Distribution: All investments made by the lender into subordinate units of AIFs that adhere to a model of priority distribution were fully subtracted from their capital funds.

Revised Notification: Key Changes:

The Revised Notification introduced a suite of carve-outs and relaxations:

Provisioning Requirement Change: Lenders must now make provisions only for the amount invested by the AIF in the borrower, not for the total investment in AIF.

No limitations for Equity Investments: If you have invested in the borrower’s equity, there is no need to report it. This rule brings good news for private equity and venture capital funds.

The revision of the notification did not include an exemption for investments made through intermediaries such as Fund of Funds or mutual funds.

AIFs using the priority distribution model only use the deduction for subordinate units when there are no non-equity investments in the AIF.

Challenges and Unaddressed Concerns:

Despite the relaxations, several challenges linger:

• The 30-day liquidation period is perceived as an inconvenience by close-ended funds, which face restrictions on the redemption and transfer of units.
• Lenders’ Role in AIFs: The Revised Notification presumes that lenders will make investment decisions for AIFs; however, this is not always the case.
• Distinguishing Legitimate Investments: Compliance requirements must effectively differentiate between genuine investments and those made solely to prolong operations indefinitely.

Proposed Solutions:

To address these challenges, the following steps are recommended:

• Extended Liquidation Timeline: Regulators should engage all stakeholders to establish a more realistic liquidation timeline.
• Penalties for Mismanagement: Consequences should be implemented for top executives involved in dubious practices such as evergreening, aligning with the recommendations of the Committee on bank board governance in India.
• Effective Risk Management: Boards of directors must implement robust internal controls and risk assessments to prevent evergreening.

Conclusion:

India’s financial landscape has positioned Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) as a crucial element, providing essential capital for startups and SMEs while fostering growth across various sectors. The flexibility and significance of AIFs in today’s investment landscape are underscored by their evolution from venture capital to diverse investment strategies.

The regulatory framework, although robust, is evolving to address the challenges and opportunities within the AIF sector. AIFs in India are poised for continued growth and impact as they drive innovation in investment strategies and align with global best practices. The ongoing reforms by the RBI demonstrate progress towards a more equitable and transparent investment environment, despite some remaining obstacles.

^[1] SEBI, Regulatory Framework Governing AIFs in India, SEBI (2012)

^[2] India Private Equity Report 2019 – Bain & Company

^[3] RBI, RBI’s Revised Notification on AIF Investments, Reserve Bank of India (2024)

King Stubb & Kasiva,
Advocates & Attorneys

Click Here to Get in Touch

New Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore | Chennai | Hyderabad | Mangalore | Pune | Kochi
Tel: +91 11 41032969 | Email: info@ksandk.com