Post-Divorce Issues: Custody, Maintenance, and Property Division in India

Posted On - 15 October, 2024 • By - Anju Nair

Introduction

Divorce, while often seen as a resolution to marital discord, brings with it a host of challenges that can significantly impact the lives of the individuals involved, particularly when children are involved. In India, post-divorce issues such as child custody, maintenance, and the division of property are critical aspects of family law that require careful consideration. 

Child Custody

  • Child custody in India is primarily governed by the Guardians and Wards Act (1890) and personal laws applicable to different religions, including the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act (1956) and Muslim Personal Law.
  • The best interests of the child are paramount in custody determinations, with the courts considering various factors, including the child’s age, needs, and the ability of each parent to provide care.

Types of Custody:

  • Physical Custody: Refers to the actual living arrangements of the child. One parent may have sole custody, or both may share physical custody.
  • Legal Custody: Involves the right to make significant decisions regarding the child’s upbringing, including education, health care, and religious instruction.
  • Joint Custody: An arrangement where both parents share custody responsibilities, allowing for involvement in the child’s life.

Custody Proceedings:

  • Custody disputes often arise during divorce proceedings or after separation. Courts encourage parents to reach amicable agreements but will intervene when disputes arise.
  • Mediation is increasingly being promoted as a means to resolve custody issues amicably, reducing the emotional strain on children and parents alike.

Challenges:

  • Societal stigma can lead to biases against fathers in custody disputes, with many judges favoring mothers, especially for younger children.  
  • Legal battles can be protracted, leading to prolonged emotional stress for children and parents.

Maintenance

  • Maintenance for spouses post-divorce is governed by several statutes, including:
  • Section 125 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS): Provides for maintenance to wives, children, and elderly parents.
  • Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act (1956): Covers maintenance claims for wives and children under Hindu law.
  • Muslim Personal Law: Provides for maintenance obligations, including the concept of “Mehr.”

Entitlement:

  • The right to maintenance is based on the premise that spouses should not be left destitute after a divorce. Maintenance can cover living expenses, education, and medical costs.
  • Courts consider various factors when determining maintenance, including the income and financial status of both parties, the duration of the marriage, and the standard of living during the marriage.

Challenges in Claiming Maintenance:

  • Many women face significant barriers when seeking maintenance, including societal stigma and financial dependence on their ex-spouses.
  • Men may also seek maintenance under certain circumstances, but the legal framework primarily focuses on the obligations of husbands towards their wives.

Enforcement Issues:

  • Despite legal provisions, enforcing maintenance orders can be challenging. Many women encounter difficulties in receiving regular payments, leading to economic hardship.
  • Courts have started adopting stricter measures to ensure compliance with maintenance orders, including garnishing wages and imposing fines on defaulters.

Property Division

  • The division of property post-divorce is governed by various personal laws, including the Hindu Succession Act (1956) and the Indian Succession Act (1925), depending on the community of the parties involved.
  • The Supreme Court has emphasized the need for equitable distribution of property during divorce proceedings.

Types of Property:

  •  Ancestral Property: Under Hindu law, ancestral property is typically inherited and may be subject to different rules regarding division.
  • Self-Acquired Property: Property acquired during the marriage is generally subject to division, and both spouses may have claims depending on contributions made during the marriage.

Division of Assets:

  • Courts consider various factors when dividing assets, including the duration of the marriage, the financial contribution of each party, and any agreements made during the marriage.
  • The lack of a standardized framework for property division can lead to disputes, with parties often contesting the valuation and division of assets.

Challenges:

  • Parties may attempt to conceal assets or undervalue property to gain an advantage in division proceedings.
  • Women, especially those with limited economic resources, may face significant challenges in asserting their rights to property, leading to economic insecurity.

Conclusion

Post-divorce issues such as child custody, maintenance, and property division are critical aspects of family law in India that require careful legal consideration. While the legal framework provides certain protections and rights for individuals, societal norms and enforcement challenges often complicate these issues.

To navigate these complex matters, individuals must seek legal counsel to understand their rights and obligations fully. Additionally, ongoing reforms in family law are essential to address the gender disparities and social stigmas that persist in post-divorce scenarios.

By promoting awareness and legal literacy, individuals can empower themselves to pursue equitable outcomes in custody, maintenance, and property division, ultimately fostering a more just and balanced approach to family law in India.

King Stubb & Kasiva,
Advocates & Attorneys

Click Here to Get in Touch

New Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore | Chennai | Hyderabad | Mangalore | Pune | Kochi
Tel: +91 11 41032969 | Email: info@ksandk.com