Legal Structures for Startups in India: Choosing Between LLPs, Private Limited, and OPCs

Introduction

Starting a business is an exciting venture, but it comes with crucial decisions that lay the foundation for future success. Among these, choosing the right legal structure is one of the most significant, as it directly impacts operational flexibility, funding prospects, compliance obligations, and the business’s overall growth trajectory. In India’s thriving startup ecosystem, entrepreneurs have access to various legal structures, with Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), Private Limited Company (PLC), and One Person Company (OPC) emerging as the most popular options.

Each of these legal entities operates under distinct regulatory frameworks, offering unique benefits tailored to specific business needs. LLPs are prized for their simplicity and operational flexibility, PLCs for their scalability and ability to attract external funding, and OPCs for catering to solo entrepreneurs seeking a corporate structure with minimal compliance. However, selecting the appropriate legal structure requires a thorough understanding of their features, compliance costs, tax implications, and legal obligations.

1. Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)

Legal Framework: The LLP structure was introduced in India under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008. LLPs combine the flexibility of a partnership with the limited liability feature of a company, making them a popular choice for professional services and smaller businesses that do not require extensive capital investment.

Key Features:

• Separate Legal Entity: LLPs have a separate legal identity from their partners, which means they can own assets and incur liabilities independently.
• Limited Liability: Partners have limited liability, meaning their personal assets are protected against business debts.
• Taxation: LLPs are taxed as per partnership firm taxation under the Income Tax Act, 1961, with a flat tax rate of 30%. A surcharge and health and education cess will be applicable if the income exceeds specified limits. LLPs are exempt from MAT (Minimum Alternate Tax), unlike companies.
• Management Structure: Managed by designated partners, with an agreement defining profit-sharing, responsibilities, and management roles.

Compliance Requirements:

• Annual Compliance: LLPs are required to file an annual statement of accounts and solvency and an annual return with the Registrar of Companies (ROC).
• Tax Filings: LLPs must file annual tax returns, including Form 8 (Statement of Accounts & Solvency) and Form 11 (Annual Return) with the MCA, and income tax returns as per the Income Tax Act, 1961.
• Audit Requirements: Audit is mandatory only if the annual turnover exceeds INR 40 lakhs or capital contribution exceeds INR 25 lakhs. LLPs operating in regulated sectors such as banking or insurance may have different audit requirements irrespective of the thresholds.

Advantages:

• Lower Compliance Costs: LLPs are easier to manage, with less stringent compliance than Private Limited Companies.
• Operational Flexibility: LLP agreements allow flexibility in defining profit-sharing ratios, making them ideal for service-based partnerships.

Limitations:

• Restrictions on Fundraising: LLPs cannot raise funds by issuing shares, limiting their attractiveness to venture capitalists or other equity investors.
• Growth Constraints: LLPs are better suited for small-to-medium businesses due to their limitations in attracting equity funding.

Best Suited For: Consulting firms, service-oriented businesses, and startups with limited capital requirements.

2. Private Limited Company (PLC)

Legal Framework: Governed by the Companies Act, 2013, Private Limited Companies are one of the most popular legal structures for startups in India, especially for businesses planning to scale up or attract external investments.

Key Features:

• Separate Legal Entity: PLCs are separate legal entities from their shareholders, providing a high level of credibility.
• Limited Liability: Shareholders’ liability is limited to the unpaid amount on their shares, protecting personal assets.
• Capital and Shares: PLCs can issue equity shares, which is advantageous for attracting investors and raising funds.
• Taxation: Subject to corporate income tax rates, with dividends now taxed in the hands of shareholders as per their applicable income tax slabs, following the abolition of the Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) in 2020.

Compliance Requirements:

• Board Meetings and Annual General Meetings (AGM): PLCs must conduct board meetings at least once every quarter and an AGM annually.
• Statutory Filings: Required to file an annual return (Form MGT-7), financial statements (Form AOC-4), and various other forms based on transactions and activities.
• Audit Compliance: Statutory audits are mandatory regardless of turnover, and PLCs must appoint an auditor within 30 days of incorporation.
• Tax Filings: Corporates must file annual tax returns, TDS returns, and other applicable tax documentation.

Advantages:

• Easy Fundraising: PLCs can raise funds by issuing shares, making them attractive to venture capitalists, angel investors, and institutional investors.
• Scalability: PLCs can expand operations, increase shareholders, and accommodate large-scale businesses.
• Investor Credibility: PLCs enjoy high credibility in the market due to their structured compliance and regulatory oversight.

Limitations:

• Higher Compliance Cost: PLCs are subject to stringent compliance requirements, including mandatory audits, board meetings, and multiple filings.
• Dividend Taxation: Dividends are taxed as per the shareholder’s income tax slab, adding to individual tax burdens.

Best Suited For: Startups with high growth potential, businesses seeking external funding, and companies requiring a structured corporate setup.

3. One Person Company (OPC)

Legal Framework: Introduced under the Companies Act, 2013, the OPC structure is designed for individual entrepreneurs who want the benefits of a corporate structure but with simplified compliance.

Key Features:

• Separate Legal Entity: OPCs are recognized as separate legal entities, offering protection to the owner’s personal assets.
• Single Ownership: Owned by a single shareholder, OPCs allow sole proprietors to operate under a corporate structure.
• Limited Liability: The single shareholder has limited liability, which safeguards personal assets.
• Taxation: OPCs are taxed at the same rate as Private Limited Companies, with dividends taxed in the hands of the sole shareholder.

Compliance Requirements:

• Conversion to PLC on Threshold Breach: OPCs must convert to a PLC if their annual turnover exceeds INR 2 crore or if paid-up capital exceeds INR 50 lakh.
• Annual Filings: OPCs must submit an annual financial statement and annual return to the ROC.
• Meetings: Though an OPC is not required to hold an AGM, it must maintain certain records and file annual returns.

Advantages:

• Simplicity: OPCs have lower compliance requirements compared to PLCs, making them manageable for solo entrepreneurs.
• Limited Liability for Sole Owners: OPCs provide personal asset protection while operating under a company structure.

Limitations:

• Single Shareholder Restriction: Only one individual can own an OPC, limiting the scope for partnership or team ownership.
• Limited Funding Potential: OPCs cannot raise equity funding, restricting their growth potential.

Best Suited For: Individual entrepreneurs, freelancers, and solo business operators who prefer a corporate structure with minimal compliance.

Legal and Strategic Considerations for Structuring Startups

1. Regulatory Compliance: Compliance obligations vary significantly. LLPs have the least, PLCs have the most stringent, and OPCs fall in between. For example, while PLCs and OPCs must appoint statutory auditors, LLPs are only required to do so if turnover or capital exceeds specified limits. Startups must factor in compliance costs and legal obligations, especially if intending to seek external investments.
2. Liability Protections:
   • LLPs and Corporates: LLPs, PLCs, and OPCs provide limited liability, safeguarding personal assets. However, shareholders and directors can be held liable if they commit fraud or fail to comply with regulatory standards.
   • Risk Mitigation for Investors: PLCs offer well-defined shareholder protections, with sections under the Companies Act (such as Section 177 for audit committees) ensuring compliance, transparency, and mitigation of operational risks.
3. Investment and Funding:
   • LLPs: Best suited for self-funded businesses, as they cannot issue shares.
   • PLCs: Compatible with investor expectations, allowing for funding through equity shares, convertible instruments, and debentures, governed under the Companies Act, 2013.
   • OPCs: Limited in external funding opportunities, as they are solely owned and are unable to issue shares.
4. Scalability:
   • Conversion and Expansion: PLCs are naturally scalable through share capital and additional shareholders. LLPs and OPCs, while easier to form, require conversions (LLP to PLC or OPC to PLC) to expand significantly, especially if they breach statutory thresholds.
5. Exit Strategy:
   • Share Transferability in PLCs: Shares in PLCs are transferable, allowing investors to exit, which is attractive to venture capitalists and private equity firms.
   • Transferability in LLPs: Transfer of rights in LLPs is more complex, often requiring mutual partner consent.

Conclusion           

Choosing the right legal structure for a startup in India is a pivotal decision that shapes its growth, compliance, and operational strategy. LLPs, PLCs, and OPCs each cater to specific business needs, governed by the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, and the Companies Act, 2013. LLPs suit businesses prioritizing flexibility and minimal compliance, PLCs are ideal for growth-oriented startups seeking external funding, and OPCs benefit solo entrepreneurs with simple compliance needs. By understanding the unique features and legal implications of each structure, entrepreneurs can make informed decisions that align with their business goals, ensuring compliance and sustainable growth.

King Stubb & Kasiva,
Advocates & Attorneys

Click Here to Get in Touch

New Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore | Chennai | Hyderabad | Mangalore | Pune | Kochi
Tel: +91 11 41032969 | Email: info@ksandk.com